College
Composition
Roaring water could be heard in the distance, but not everyone picked up on
it. Not yet anyways. My Pastor said that as long as he lived, even
if he made it to a hundred, he would never forget that day.
It was the end of summer and my church’s youth group went to Holeb for a
vacation. Not every group decides to go
halfway between unused logging roads and Canada for a vacation, but that’s
where we went. We had a group of about a dozen kids, plus our pastor and youth leader. On our last full day, we
decided to go on a hike.
After
crashing through the woods on deer-forsaken trails for about ten minutes, I
heard the dull, faraway sound of roaring water.
What I heard was The River. When we came out of the forest, we stood on
a rocky river bank. The river was fifteen
feet wide and swollen from the recent rain.
Further down the river it funneled into a small pool, then poured
out into a raging, twenty-foot waterfall.
Most of the youth group carefully
picked their way down the embankment around the waterfall to follow the river downstream, but I had other
plans. If I could get to the other side
of the river then I could climb onto a giant, beautiful rock that overlooked
the river below. My plan seemed
infallible, so I asked permission to cross.
My youth leader rubbed his chin. He
sized up the gap that I wanted to cross, and finally gave me his permission.
He
was only 18, probably too young to be making judgment calls like that, but I
gave it no second thought. The river funneled
into a three-foot-wide space of roaring white water, and it was there that I
jumped across. I landed on the other
side with clammy fists and heart pounding.
Without glancing back, I made my way to the view.
It was to die for.
When
I had drunk my fill of landscapes, I went back to my crossing. There I found Hannah waiting for me. Hannah and I were good friends, and bunk mates for the trip. She was asking if she could come across with
me. If my youth leader was under-qualified
in choosing this kind of decision, I was much worse. For a moment, I hesitated. She was a little bit timid, and I was surprised
that she wanted to cross at all. But my
resolve was broken by her hopeful eyes, and I told her that she could come over.
There
we stood, facing each other and only separated by a few feet of white water. A mentor of mine told me just this year to be
careful. “Be careful, Danielle,” he
said. “You are apt to project your strengths on other people.” But that piece of life-saving advice wouldn’t
be imparted to me for years to come, and in my head on that day I was sure that
nothing would go wrong. This is real
life, and bad things like that don’t happen.
Things would be fine. She would
make the jump.
Then
she didn’t.
Before either of us could
scream, she disappeared into the angry, foaming water. After a few moments, they lasted so long in my
mind, she popped up in the pool above the waterfall. She immediately grabbed onto a log that had
fallen across the pool, and she hung on for all she was worth. She was a small girl though, and the current
fought her grasp. With every second it gained on her. She wouldn’t last
long.
By
now the scene had attracted some attention from those on the shore. Quickly, our pastor made his way to where the
pool poured out into the waterfall. Our
youth leader, on whose face was written every ounce of his distress, had kicked off his
shoes and was trying to inch his way out onto the fragile log that Hannah was
holding onto. I didn’t know what to do,
but I knew that if I was to be of any help, I would have to be on the other
side. Without giving it another thought,
I jumped.
I
didn’t make it. Blinded by the raging
water, I had no idea which way was up. Luckily, the buoyancy of my body was enough
to bring me to the surface and before I could think, I was beside Hannah,
hugging the log for dear life.
I
felt like I was in a dream, and though I am sure people were shouting, I didn’t
hear a thing. I noticed that my shirt
had risen with the water and I was immediately self-conscious. I couldn’t think of a way to fix it without
letting go of my hold though. Then I began
thinking about the lesson we had that last night. It was about Heaven. I thought to myself that this wouldn’t be
such a bad way to go, provided that it ended quickly at the bottom. Would there be jagged rocks waiting to skewer us? Would the force of the water keep us under 'till we drowned?
Somehow,
I came to my senses and realized where I was.
This wasn't over yet, and I didn’t want it to be. So I began looking for a way out. To my right the log was resting on a boulder
that served as the far side of the little pool.
I shouted over the din of the
water to Hannah, and we began sliding over to the boulder. It was hard work and our nerves were shot,
but we both dragged our bodies out of the water and up onto the boulder.
We
sat still for a moment, panting from the exertion. Then we both stood up and made our way to the
bank. We passed our crossing without
even a second glance, and kept walking upriver.
We walked a long ways until the river was shallow enough for us to
cross. We grasped each others hands as
we dipped our feet back in the water, and crossed on unsteady feet.
There was a whole posse of people
waiting for us by the time we made it back to the group. People said I was so brave to jump
in after her like that. I quickly
corrected them, but somehow everyone still thought I saved her. Conversation rose about the incident. Questions of “Where were you when they went
in?” and “Do you think they would’ve
died if they had gone over the falls?” were swapped back and forth.
I was silent through it all. After a few minutes, their flippant response
to the situation overwhelmed me, and I walked a little ways off so that I wouldn't hear them. I couldn’t blame
them, they weren’t in that water. It wasn’t
their life they were talking about. I
sat down next to my pastor and youth leader on a rock that overlooked the
river, and set about wringing out my hair and shirt.
My youth leader had his arms folded
over his chest, with a more tired look than I had ever seen him
wear. My pastor was standing, facing the
river. When I first broke out onto the
bank, I would’ve called the sound of the river comforting, maybe even
lulling. We all knew better now. My Pastor sighed and commented, “For as long
as I live, even if live to be a hundred, I’ll never forget this day.”
I just quietly nodded, and watched as the river
rushed away.
I'm going to play a dirty trick on you and do something no teacher should do: I'm going to compare you to another student writer. This one:
ReplyDeletehttp://christinadaae.blogspot.com/2013/10/prompt-17.html
That's a piece that knows where it's going, what it's all about, and that is under the writer's control. It takes something so small as to be practically invisible and turns it into a good piece.
ReplyDeleteThis memoir takes something huge--the possibility of an early and tragic death of two girls on a church outing--and drains the hugeness out of it. I think that happens because you want to include everything and think this piece is about including everything. I don't agree: it has to find its point, its center, its focus, its purpose.
As always, you write well here, but sometimes that isn't enough. There has to be something on the page beyond good writing.
I'd call this a de-briefing--you need to recount every detail you remember to help yourself with the enormity of thing. But having done that here, having gotten it out of your system to some extent, then the writer has to start thinking about audience and what is needed to turn a string of events into a narrative essay.
ReplyDeleteSo the first comment says I sound like me?
ReplyDeleteI wasn't very happy with it myself when I turned it it. It's flat.
ReplyDeleteBut how do I change that? Should I ax the beginning and centralize on the action? That might be more considerate of the reader's attention. Should I try to throw in more mood on how dangerous the situation was? Was there too much denouement?
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe first comment: the piece about work is a perfect little gem--all I meant was that in this piece you ought to imitate that Della person in that other class.
ReplyDeleteThis piece, though: yes, part of it is the inordinately long windup. But I can't say categorically that that beginning is wrong. It depends on what the piece is really about: is it about a near-death experience? If so, a lot of the beginning is not helpful.
But an argument could be made that it's really about negligent adult oversight--if that's what it's about, the material in the beginning might be very relevant.
Same issue with the denouement--if this is about fear and courage and mistaken impressions, the denouement may work. If it's about something else, maybe not.
"It was to die for."
ReplyDeleteSo strange for me to see this. I appreciate the irony, but all I can really hear is my mother warning me away from yiddish-inflected speech, lest anyone think we were that type of Jew.
From "The NTC's Dictionary of American Slang and Colloquial Expressions," 3rd edition, 2000, page 436:
"TO DIE FOR -- important or desirable enough to die for; worth dying for. EXAMPLES: This chocolate cake is to die for! We had a beautiful room at the hotel and the service was to die for."
Unfortunately the NTC Dictionary does not give an exact date or explain, in any way, how the phrase entered the English language.
Here's a more current explanation:
"And, Yiddish-influenced-English has contributed more than its "fair share," (Don't get me started, Don't ask, Get outta here, To die for, Enough already)."
Your rewrites can be pretty darned impressive! This has all the focus, menace, dark corners, odd angles--all the stuff version 1 fuzzed is here in sharp relief. Whew, Danielle, this is a good job!
ReplyDeleteI always look for 'good lines'--and your "watched as the river rushed away." is a corker. Simple and very effective.